Chinese Churches and World Mission

Posted · 6 Comments

Is the BCEC a Chinese church? Well, naturally it must be. I mean, after all the full name of BCEC is Birmingham Chinese Evangelical Church. The very word Chinese is smack-dab in the middle of our name.

So then is a Chinese church exclusive only to Chinese people? And isn’t that racist? And shouldn’t Chinese people mix with the society that they’re in? Why have a Chinese church at all?

These are questions that linger around any English-speaking congregation in a Chinese church. If the majority of the people in the church speak English already, why don’t they just go to an English church? Why should they bother going to a Chinese church at all? Actually, God’s church should be an international church, full of different races and faces all worshipping together.

This past Sunday was missions weekend: when we have the honour of a German-Jewish Christian–former missionary in Malaysia–as the keynote speaker, questions of culture, exclusivity, identity, and God’s church all come rising to the surface. (btw, Martin Goldsmith is a fantastic speaker and his messages, along with some notes from the weekend, are available online). And of course at the BCEC, it’s our responsibility and duty to raise and address these questions.

And so, in no particular order, here are some thoughts on the Chinese church in Britain.

1) This country needs every good church they can get.
Perhaps unlike America or Canada, where a plethora of good churches abound, the UK remains spiritually stagnant. We’re moving to a generation that is beyond post-Christianity, to one where the message of the gospel has not been heard at all. There will be people born in this country whose parents and grandparents have not heard or accepted the message of Jesus. It means then that there is a great need to be part of any good church community available. Would I say BCEC is a good church? All I can say is that we are still learning and trying to love God with all our heart, soul, mind, & strength, and love our neighbour as ourselves.

2) God loves different cultures.
In Genesis 11, God does a scattering of nations, essentially birthing a diversity of cultures.
In Genesis 12, he chooses one, the tribe of Abraham, to be his people. From them all nations will be blessed.
Throughout the Old Testament we discover God’s relationship with his people, the Jews, and God’s mission for his people. (Martin Goldsmith put a nice diagram on this.)
But through Jesus, we see a fulfilment of God’s plan: not to segregate but to “draw all people to myself.” (John 12:32). And we see how God’s plan is not one of exclusion, but one that brings greater glory to himself.
We have this amazing picture in the book of Revelation – “After this I looked, and there before me was a great multitude that no one could count, from every nation, tribe, people and language, standing before the throne and before the Lamb. They were wearing white robes and were holding palm branches in their hands.”

And we begin to realise that the diversity of culture, the diversity of language, and the diversity of people groups brings greater glory to God. This diversity reflects the multi-faceted beauty of God.

3) Chinese culture has something to offer
Often times, we can reject our culture, saying Western society is better. We might complain about parental restriction, or frustrations about what Chinese holidays are like, or whether we talk too loudly in the library. 😛 On the other hand, we might complain about Western culture. The rubbish on the media, for example, or the lack of discipline. But what is more helpful to realise is that we are not at war with another culture. Rather, God has created us to contribute to each other’s lives. All cultures have cultural blind-spots. No one culture has a monopoly on God. That’s the beauty of him. And when we’re commanded to love one another, it’s not a mandate to culturally dilute but rather for different cultures to speak blessing into each other.

4) English Speaking congregations can’t be culturally exclusive
One of the reasons I don’t call our church by its full name (Birmingham Chinese Evangelical Church) is because I realise that for some, thinking that a church is only for Chinese people will put them off coming. The truth of the matter is, if we believe that God has placed us in our situations for a purpose, then the people we as ambassadors of Christ come in contact with will become our focus.

This means that if we want to bless the people around us and invite them to church, those people may or may not be Chinese. So it is (hopefully) inevitable that our congregation becomes more and more ethnically diverse. But a church’s desire shouldn’t be ethnic diversity. Instead, it is the desire is to love God more and love our neighbours more. Never forget that.

5) Jesus’ Love
Lepers, women, Gentiles, Samaritans, Romans, criminals – you name them, and Jesus’ love extended to them. There is no greater motivation for us than to realise that we belong to Christ first; culture is but one way our love for him is expressed.

These were some thoughts from our Mission Weekend.
Martin Goldsmith’s messages: Saturday Talk 1
Saturday Talk 2
Notes on Talk 1 & 2
Sunday Message

This week’s study is on Matthew 1

Check out our Sunday Messages page or our Resources page for more sermons, Bible studies, and notes.

picture taken from Gene Luen Yang’s graphic novel, American Born Chinese, p26.

6 Responses to "Chinese Churches and World Mission"
  1. sam says:

    Some food for thought champ 🙂 indeed I have found that being an ‘international’ church can put off some locals to come too. One lady told me that her mum who is a Christian asked her not to go to an int’l church because they maybe of bad influence. How sad is that?

  2. Sam says:

    Hey I bumped into Matt C at the HK sevens last night and he told me that MCCC is now more of a multi-cultural ’emergent’ church. Would love to go back and pay a visit to the church where I committed my life to Christ 🙂

  3. Keith So says:

    The chinese church and world mission message quite struck me as I am currently at the cross road of joining a chinese church or an english speaking local church. The reason being I currently experience problems in chinese church that some chinese have a lot of inherent ingrained cultural behaviour which tend to block us in worshiping God. I had tried some local churches too but fount them a bit too liturgical.
    Would BCEC be another option?

  4. bert says:

    Hi Sam,

    Sorry for the belated reply. Yah, Matt C. is a wannabe “emergent.” haha. you should come back and visit MCCC sometime. I haven’t been in eons myself. We are putting together a young professionals conference though… Matt C’s gonna help me out with that.

    How are u doing?

  5. bert says:

    Hi Keith,

    Yeah, there are definitely cultural “idiosyncrasies” in Chinese culture. As I suppose there being quirks in every culture. I’m discovering church life is less about just what feels right, as it is also about committing to people – even if you don’t like them all that much.

    BCEC is hardly a perfect church. We’re not liturgical enough for some, but still too liturgical for others. But I like to think the people are nice, and pursuing their relationship with God and the teaching is decent. Anyone else want to share their thoughts on the BCEC?

    • keith says:

      Hi Bert
      Thank you for your response. May be one of the “idiosyncrasies” in Chinese culture is too committing to people; too eager to maintain the number. When we spent a lot of energy trying to organize celebration, birthday parties, and games to keep people, hoping to create a ‘home’ feeling, we lose our mission of being a church. A community who are called out to meet and to celebrate discipleship.
      I am glad that you think BCEC is a church where nice people are pursuing their relationship with God and the teaching is decent. No wonder you mentioned your church has grown from the size of a small family gathering to that even wing wah could not accommodate. Praise the Lord and may God add people to your church everyday every week.
      May be I shall try to visit you one day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *